1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Hollywood Movies

'City of Ember' Movie Review

About.com Rating 2.5

By , About.com Guide

Harry Treadaway and Saoirse Ronan in 'City of Ember.'

© Fox Walden
City of Ember is a difficult film to recommend to even the most fervent sci-fi/fantasy fans. The film's lacking depth and unless you're familiar with the story going in, there's nothing about this cinematic version of Jeanne Duprau's book that'll make audiences want to become involved in the lives of any of these characters onscreen. Duprau's book has a huge following, and Fox Walden will need those fans to support the film in order for it to find any success at the box office or on DVD. Nothing about the trailer or the story really engages those not already in love with the source material.

The Story

The world has become uninhabitable and the only hope for the survival of mankind is to create a fully functioning city way down deep in the earth. Scientists and scholars have determined that the city should be able to sustain life for 200 years at which point the surface of the planet will likely be in good enough shape for whoever's left down below to come up and rebuild. All of this is laid out in a set of instructions enclosed in a special box. The plan is for every mayor of the city of Ember to pass the box and its secret contents down to the next mayor until the countdown clock on the outside of the box clicks down to 000. At that time the box will open, the instructions can be read, and the citizens can make their way out of Ember.

But as often happens with the carefully laid plans of mice and men, things go horribly wrong. The 7th mayor dies suddenly without passing the box on to his successor. With the importance of its contents lost, the box is left on a shelf in a closet to conclude its countdown to 00 with no one the wiser.

Fast-forward 200+ years from the creation of Ember and the generator that provides the electricity for the entire city is dying a slow, laborious death. Lina (Saoirse Ronan) and Doon (Harry Treadaway), two teenagers just assigned their full-time jobs, seem to be the only people in the city who are not only worried about the generator, but who are determined to do something about it.

However, despite the obvious evidence that the city is fast becoming a death trap, no one in power - including the current mayor (played by Bill Murray) - wants the youngsters to succeed. With the help of just a couple of adults, the two teens must figure out the secrets of the box and the way out of Ember.

The Cast

Saoirse Ronan and Harry Treadaway are terrific as the enterprising teens. Their characters are mixtures of MacGyver, Indiana Jones, and Einstein, and both Ronan and Treadaway are believable figures in this twisty sci-fi environment. The film's adult stars – Murray, Tim Robbins, Toby Jones, and Mary Kay Place – have little to do other than to look menacing or supportive, as the case may be.

The Bottom Line

There is absolutely nothing to criticize about the sets of City of Ember. The city is a living, breathing character which is exactly what director Gil Kenan was striving for. Ember's streets, tunnels, and the generator at the heart of the city look fabulous.

The sets are great, the two young leads are great, so why did I feel so disconnected from the story? There's a minimal amount of explanation given as to why these people are living underground and then bam!, the film just takes off. I felt like I'd walked into a movie halfway in progress with no one around to fill me in on what I missed. That said, I'm not sure adding another 10 minutes or more to the beginning of the film to give the audience a better idea of what we were in for would have done anything to improve the film.

This is a movie with a very specific target audience – young people who've read the book – and it will play solely to that demographic. And being that I'm not included in that description, this film wasn't for me - and I felt it. It's not like a Harry Potter movie where you don't feel as neglected if you haven't read the source material.

The Massive Generator and the Mighty River in 'City of Ember.'
© Fox Walden
Too many questions are left dangling that may have been addressed in the book. Why haven't any stories of life outside of Ember been passed down from generation to generation? If the box is a central part of each mayor's official portrait up until the 8th mayor, why hasn't anyone gone looking for it? Why aren't more people searching for a way out of the city since it's falling to pieces? Does everyone want to just die in the dark once the generator fails?

In City of Ember, the fate of mankind rests on a bunch of underground dwellers who've bred, with the exception of only a handful of independent thinkers, the intelligence out of themselves. Civilization is doomed and so is this movie if it's unable to draw in fans of the book.

GRADE: C

City of Ember was directed by Gil Kenan and is rated PG for mild peril and some thematic elements.

Theatrical Release Date: October 10, 2008

User Reviews Write Review

Explore Hollywood Movies

About.com Special Features

Holiday Central

What to eat, where to go, fun things to do and how to save money on the perfect gifts. More >

The Best Top 40 Pop Songs

Is your favorite song on our list? More >

  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Hollywood Movies
  4. Films By Genre
  5. Teen Movies
  6. City of Ember
  7. City of Ember Movie Review - Review of City of Ember Starring Saoirse Ronan

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.