Hollywood Movies

  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Hollywood Movies

"The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" Movie Review

A Very Ordinary 'Extraordinary'

By Rebecca Murray, About.com

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie

Stuart Townsend, Sean Connery and Jason Flemyng in "The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen"

20th Century Fox
I’m sure there are comic book fans out there who will cringe while reading this review. For that, I apologize now and suggest that you read no further. If you've read my reviews of “The Hulk” or “X2” then you’re probably aware of the fact that I don’t read comic books. Nothing personal, they’ve just never drawn my interest. In fact, my knowledge of comic books is so limited that I didn’t know – prior to reading all the production notes – that “The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen” was even based on a comic. So if you’re looking for a review that compares the two media, I’m going to gently suggest looking elsewhere. Go now before it’s too late. Gentle enough?

Anyway, a group of literary figures are recruited to save the British Empire and the world – in that order. First recruited to this secret league is Allan Quatermain, adventurer/explorer/Sean Connery. He’s living a life of leisure in Africa after decades of traveling the planet. Why Africa? A witch doctor assured him Africa would never let him die and if that happened to you, wouldn’t you make Africa your permanent place of residence? After a little arm-twisting in the form of a brutal gun battle, Quatermain agrees to help save his former homeland and the planet – again, in that order.

Enter ‘M’ (Richard Roxburgh), a mysterious man with a mission. He’s the mastermind maneuvering the eclectic (I could have used multifaceted etc. but enough with the M’s) league into place. Besides Quatermain, M recruits the inventor Captain Nemo (Naseeruddin Shah), “Dracula” vampiress Mina Harker (Peta Wilson), and Rodney Skinner aka The Invisible Man (Tony Curran). To fill out the group The League, led by Quatermain, invites the ageless Dorian Gray (Stuart Townsend), the notorious Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde (Jason Flemyng) and hotshot American Secret Service Agent Tom Sawyer (Shane West).

Why these people? I’ve absolutely no clue. They’ve got nothing in common, some aren’t even hero-types in the classic sense. And what’s with a vampire who can endure sunlight? They could never do that in “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” – not even when it would have helped advance the storyline. And if it's a literary reference from "Dracula," then it should have been explained in the movie. Most people are stuck with the impression vampires can't stand the sunlight and it's a confusing plot point. And why, after adding Mina Harker, doesn’t it become the League of Extraordinary Gentlepeople? She’s tough and can hold her own, but she’s not a gentleman. But I digress.

The League must quickly travel to Venice, Italy where a madman known as the Fantom (why not Phantom?) plans to blow up a meeting of world leaders. Captain Nemo’s ‘Nautilus’ provides a quicker-than-should-be-reasonably-possible ride to Venice. The group must find the bombs and stop the collapse of THE WORLD AS WE KNOW IT. Or the world as they knew it back in the 1800s. They also must deal with a traitor in their midst and a script that works against them.

Someone said to me, “It could have been much worse.” That’s a ringing endorsement if I ever heard one. It’s not a disaster but it’s not the adventure movie of the year either. The CGI’s not visually up to 2003 standards, you aren’t provided with enough backstory to understand all the nuances, and even Sean Connery seems to be lost. But the acting’s decent and there are a few fun literary references so I guess “it could have been much worse” is just about right.

GRADE: C-

"The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" was directed by Stephen Norrington (full cast/crew list) and is rated PG-13 for intense sequences of fantasy violence, language, and innuendo.

Explore Hollywood Movies

About.com Special Features

Hollywood Movies

  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Hollywood Movies
  4. Films By Genre
  5. Dramas
  6. League of Extraordinary
  7. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Movie Review

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.